Adobe PDFPhysician-Assisted Suicide

Physician-assisted suicide must be prohibited for people with intellectual disability (ID)1 due to the inherent risk of undue influence.

Issue

Physician-assisted suicide occurs when a physician provides a medical means for death, usually a prescription for a lethal amount of medication that the patient takes on his or her own2. As the nation, individual states, and various interest groups consider the adoption of physician-assisted suicide policies, it is essential that people with ID have their rights and interests protected. Historical ignorance, prejudice, and discrimination against people with ID continue. Education of policy makers and society at large is critical.

Major problems that exist are:

  • The documented history of denial of basic rights and medical care, including nutrition and hydration, places the lives of people with ID at extraordinary risk.
  • Despite well-intended laws designed to protect people with ID, our constituents can be unduly influenced by authority figures such as doctors, health care workers, social workers, family, guardian/conservators, and friends, resulting in a lack of true informed consent.
  • The current system of health services, particularly managed care, provides economic incentives for rationing health care, and can lead to the encouragement of physician-assisted suicide.
  • Society often incorrectly perceives that people with ID, by definition, have a poor quality of life.

Public perception on this issue is sometimes confused with specific issues related to advance directives3 and death with dignity.

Position

We strongly oppose physician-assisted suicide for people with ID and believe it requires strong and absolute vigilance because:

  • The death of any person with ID by way of physician-assisted suicide is never acceptable and should not be allowed by law under any circumstances;
  • Laws and procedures, however strict, are not sufficient to protect people with ID from being coerced into ending their lives;
  • When the person is seriously ill and in pain, the use of appropriate medical or palliative care to reduce and/or eliminate pain and discomfort can and must be provided.

Adopted:

Adopted: Board of Directors, The Arc
July 29, 2012

Congress of Delegates, The Arc
October 27, 2012


1 "People with intellectual disabilities and/or developmental disabilities” refers to those defined by AAIDD classification and DSM IV.  In everyday language they are frequently referred to as people with cognitive, intellectual and/or developmental disabilities although the professional and legal definitions of those terms both include others and exclude some defined by DSM IV.

2 Physician-assisted suicide: Occurs when a physician provides a medical means for death, usually a prescription for a lethal amount of medication that the patient takes on his or her own. (In euthanasia, the physician directly and intentionally administers a substance to cause death.) (Ethics Manual, American College of Physicians, 2012). The American College of Physicians does not support legalization of physician-assisted suicide or euthanasia. “After much consideration, the College concluded that making physician-assisted suicide legal raised serious ethical, clinical, and social concerns and that the practice might undermine patient trust; distract from reform in end-of-life care; and be used in vulnerable patients, including those who are poor, are disabled [sic], or are unable to speak for themselves or minority groups who have experienced discrimination.”  The American Medical Association also opposes physician assisted suicide: “allowing physicians to participate in assisted suicide would cause more harm than good. Physician-assisted suicide is fundamentally incompatible with the physician’s role as healer, would be difficult or impossible to control, and would pose serious societal risks.” (Code of Ethics, American Medical Association, 1996).  As of March of 2012, only two states, Oregon and Washington, specifically authorize physicians, in limited circumstances, to assist suicide.  These states, however, do not allow for the practice to be used in situations where the person choosing to commit suicide lacks mental competence.

3 See The Arc’s health care position statement regarding advanced directives.